Students’ responses to vignettes featuring cultural differences: Pondering empathy gaps, value judgments, and the promotion of ‘partiality’ in teaching empathy
Keywords:Empathy, Social work education, Non-judgmental, Diversity, Partiality
The promotion of empathy and non-judgmental helping is familiar discourse in social work education and practice. These concepts are considered to be crucial to effective intervention. The primary aim of qualitative classroom-based research undertaken at a regional Australian university in 2009 and 2011 was to explore the concept of empathy through the use of selected, real life vignettes. Pondering students’ responses to two, of a total of eight, vignettes across very similar projects, those vignettes featuring an Aboriginal elder, and inter-country adoption, extends previous discussion of these findings. The combined findings offer suggestion that more proactive engagement on the topic of empathy could transform students’ cognitive understanding of empathy and non-judgmental helping, into a mastery of deeper, felt empathy, particularly for working across diverse cultural contexts. Considering the concept of ‘partiality’ may offer direction in this regard.
Abrama, L. and Gibson, P. (2007) Teaching Notes. Reframing multicultural education: Teaching white privilege in the social work curriculum. Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 41 no. 1, pp.147-160.
Alma, H. and Smaling, A. (2006) The meaning of empathy and imagination in health care and health studies. International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Wellbeing, vol.1 no.4 pp.195-211.
Batson, C. D, Chang, J. Orr, R. and Rowland, J. (2002) Empathy, attitudes and action: Can feeling for a member of a stigmatized group motivate one to help the group? Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, vol. 28 pp.1656-1666.
Bennett, M.J. (2001). The empathic healer: An endangered species? New York: Academic Press. Boulton, R. (1987) People skills. Sydney, New South Wales: Simon and Schuster.
Carse, A. (2005). The moral contours of empathy. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 8, 169-195.
Dadds, M. (2008) Empathic validity in practitioner research. Educational Action Research, vol. 16 no. 2 pp. 279-290. Davis, C. (2003) Empathy as transcendence. Topics in Geriatric Rehabilitation, vol. 19 no. 4 pp.265-274.
De Vignemont, F. and Singer, T. (2006) The empathic brain: How, when and why? Trends in Cognitive Sciences, vol. 10 no. 10 pp.435-441.
Dominelli, L. (2008) Anti-racist social work. (3rd ed). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Duan, C. and Hill, C. (1996) The state of empathy research. Journal of Counseling Psychology, vol. 43 no. 3 pp. 261-274.
Eckermann, A., Dowd, T., Chong, E., Nixon, L., Gray, R. and Johnson, S. (2006) Binan goonj. Bridging cultures in Aboriginal health. Sydney, New South Wales: Elsevier Australia.
Eisenberg, N. (1982. The development of prosocial behaviour. New York: Academic Press. Figley, C.R. (2002) Treating compassion fatigue. New York: Brunner-Routledge.
Fook, J. (1999) Critical reflectivity in education and practice. In B. Pease and J. Fook, Transforming social work practice (pp. 195- 208). St Leonards, New South Wales: Allen and Unwin.
Furlong, M. and Wight, J. (2011) Promoting ‘critical awareness’ and critiquing ‘cultural competence’: Towards disrupting received professional knowledges. Australian Social Work, vol. 64, no.1 pp. 38-54.
Furman, R. (2006) Using poetry and written exercise to teach empathy. The Journal of Poetry Therapy, vol. 18 no. 2 pp.103-110.
Gair, S. (2011) Exploring empathy embedded in social work ethics curricula: A classroom inquiry reinforces the case for advancing deeper empathy. Advances in Social Work, vol. 12 no. 2 pp. 329-344.
Gair, S. (2009) More on empathy: Considering student responses and Edith Stein’s framework for a fuller, transformative empathy. Advances in Social Welfare Education, vol. 11 no. 1 pp.51-69.
Garcia, B. and Van Soest, D. (1999) Teaching about diversity and oppression. Journal of Teaching in Social Work, vol. 18 nos.1/2 pp.149-167.
Gardner, F. (2006)Working in human service organisations. Melbourne: Oxford University Press. Geldard, G. (1989) Basic personal counselling. Brisbane, Queensland: Prentice Hall.
Gerdes, K., Segal, E., Jackson, K. and Mullins, J. (2011) Teaching empathy: A framework rooted in social, cognitive neuroscience and social justice. Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 47 no.11 pp. 9-131.
Gibbs, L. and Gambrill, E. (1999) Critical thinking for social workers. 1000 Oaks, California: Pine Forge Press.
Gutsell, J. and Inzlicht, M. (2010) Empathy constrained: Prejudice predicts reduced mental simulation of actions during observations of outgroups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, vol. 46 pp. 841-845.
Harris, P. (2006) In search of belonging. London: British Association for Adoption and Fostering.
Harris, R. and Foreman-Peck, L. (2004) Stepping into other people’s shoes: Teaching and assessing empathy in the Secondary History curriculum. International Journal of Historical Learning, Teaching and Research, vol. 4 no.2 pp. 1-14.
Haigh, M. (2009) Fostering cross-cultural empathy with non-western curricula structures. Journal of Studies in International Education, vol. 13 no.2 pp.271-284.
Hart, S. (2000) Thinking through teaching. London: David Fulton Publishers. Heron, J. (1992) Feelings and personhood. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage.
Hoffman, M. (1982) Development of prosocial motivation: Empathy and guilt. In N.Eisenberg (Ed.), The development of prosocial behavior (pp 281-311). New York: Academic Press.
Hojat, M. (2007) Empathy in patient care. New York: Springer.
Hojat, M., Gonnella, J., Nasca, T., Mangione, S., Vergare, M. and Magee, M. (2002) Physician empathy: Definition,
components and relationship to gender and specialty. American Journal of Psychology, vol. 159 pp.1563-1569. Retrieved from http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/Howe, D. (2008) The emotionally intelligent social worker. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hugman, R. (2005) New approaches in ethics for the caring professions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kirton, D. (1999) Perspectives on ‘race’ and adoption: The view of student social workers. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 29 no. 5 pp. 779-796.
Kohut, H. (1977) The restoration of the self. New York: National Universities Press.
Lee, M., and Greene, G. (1999) A social constructivist framework for integrating cross-cultural issues in teaching clinical social work. Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 35 no. 1 pp.21-37.
Lee, J., Crolley-Simic, J. and Vonc, M.E. (2013) MSW students’ attitudes toward transracial adoption. Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 9 no.1 pp.122-135.
McDonald, S. (2001) Bridging the gap, Paper presented to the Feminism and Participatory Action Research Conference. Boston College. Retrieved from http://ggsc.wnmu.edu/gap/mcdonald.htm
Meeuwesen, L., Harmsen, J.A.M., Bersen, R.M.D. and Bruijnzeels, M.A. (2006) Do Dutch doctors communicate differently with immigrant patients than with Dutch patients. Social Science and Medicine, vol. 63 pp. 2407-2417.
Mercer, S. and Reynolds, W. (2002) Empathy and quality of care. British Journal of General Practice, vol. 52(Supplement), S9-12. Mlcek, S. (2013) Are we doing enough to develop cross cultural competencies for social work? British Journal of Social Work.
Noddings, N. (2003) Caring. Berkeley, California: University of California Press.
Pedersen, A. and Barlow, F. (2008) Theory to social action: A university-based strategy targeting prejudice against Aboriginal Australians. Australian Psychologist, vol. 43 no. 3 pp.148-159.
Pedersen, A., Beven, J., Walker, I. and Griffiths B. (2004) Attitudes towards Indigenous Australians: The role of empathy and guilt. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, vol. 14 pp.233-249.
Pedersen, P., Crethar, H. and Carlson, J. (2008) Inclusive cultural empathy. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Pelling, N., Bowers, R. and Armstrong, P. (2006) The practice of counselling. Victoria: Thomson.
Pinderhughes, E. (1989) Understanding race, ethnicity and power. New York: The Free Press.
Quince, T., Parker, R., Wood, D. and Benson, J. (2011) Stability of empathy among undergraduate medical students: A longitudinal study at one UK medical school. BMC Medical Education, Vol. 11, no. 90. Retrieved from www.biomedicalcentral. com/1472-6920/11/90
Ramsden, P. (1992) Learning to teach in higher education. London: Kogan Page.
Rasoal, C., Eklund, J. and Hansen, E. (2011) Towards a conceptualization of ethnocultural empathy. Journal of Social, Evolutionary and Cultural Psychology, vol. 5 no. 1 pp. 1-13.
Read, P. (1990) Charles Perkins. A biography. Ringwood, Victoria: Viking Penguin Books.
Redmond, M. (2010) Safe space oddity: Revisiting critical pedagogy. Journal of Teaching in Social Work, vol. 30 no.1 pp1-14.
Rogers, C. (1956/1992) The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, vol. 60 no. 6 pp. 827-832.
Scanlon, C. (2008, January 23) ‘Claiming the high moral ground can be a low act’. The Australian, p. 27.
Schutz, A. (1973) The phenomenology of the social world. (translated G. Walsh and F. Lehnert), Heinemann, London.
Stitt, S. and Gibbs, D. (2007) Non-offending mothers of sexually abused children: The hidden victims. Institute of Technology Blanchardstown (ITB) Journal, vol. 15, pp. 13- 37.
Taylor, C., and White, S. (2006) Knowledge and reasoning in social work: Educating for humane judgment. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 36 no.6 p. 937-954.
Thompson, N. (2006) Anti-discriminatory practice. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Tong, R. (1997) Feminist perspectives on empathy as an epistemic skill and caring as a moral virtue. Journal of Medical Humanities, vol. 18 no. 3 pp. 154-168.
Travis, M.A. (2010) Beyond empathy: Narrative distancing and ethics in Toni Morrison’s Beloved and J. M. Coetzee’s Disgrace.
Journal of Narrative Theory, vol. 40 no. 2 pp. 231-250.
Trevithick, P. (2005) Social work skills. Maidenhead, Berkshire: Open University Press.
White, C., Perlman, R., Fantone, J. and Kumagai, A. (2010) The interpretive project: A creative educational approach to foster medical students’ reflections and advancing humanistic medicine. Reflective Practice, vol. 11 no. 4 pp.517-527.
Wispe, L. (1987) History of the concept of empathy. In N. Eisenberg and J. Strayer (Eds.), Empathy and its development (pp 17- 37), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wong, R. Y. L. (2004) Knowing through discomfort: A mindfulness-based critical social work pedagogy. Critical Social Work, vol. 5 no. 1. Retrieved from http://www.uwindsor.ca/criticalsocialwork/2004-volume-5-no-1
Young, A. (2009) Families of choice: A qualitative study of Australian families formed through inter-country adoption (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Department of Sociology and Social Policy, University of Sydney.
Copyright (c) 2013 Australian and New Zealand Social Work and Welfare Education and Research
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.